Emily, I really appreciate your thorough research, breakdown & comparisons with the publications and also all the background details you included that clears out some of the misunderstandings and mystery surrounding the editions. The correction lists you provide are such a valuable resource in themselves to create a very easy straightforward path for others. Thank you so much for doing this & your help always. L
Hi Emily - I own Additional Banerji Protocols from the Clinic by Nimisha Parekh and have found it to be a valuable resource as well. It was recently shared with me that some people feel the book isn’t trustworthy because they believe she only visited the Banerji Clinic for one day and then compiled protocols from others. Have you heard of people questioning her credibility or know what may have led to that?
Hi Nichole, I don't know precisely how much time Nimisha spent at the clinics, but the only place that I heard similar things (as you shared) was during my year at the Academy of Practical Homeopathy. Joette Calabrese basically does not acknowledge the Additional Banerji Protocols book, and yet when test time came, the protocol for Diabetes, which is only found in the Additional Protocols book, was expected to be known on the tests. The Additional Protocols are perfectly in line with the original ones, I have used them extensively, and in a short course I did with Nimisha it is clear she got to know the Banerjis, and also uses the protocols herself extensively. :)
Thank you - that’s very helpful. I do have two follow-up questions about the skin cancer protocol on page 60.
First, what does “eAM” mean? I checked the abbreviation key in the front of the book but didn’t see it listed. Does it stand for every alternate month, or every morning?
Second, a practicing homeopath who completed Joette’s Academy suggested a different protocol: Antimonium crudum 6C and Arsenicum album 200C, 2D. In your opinion, would it be better to follow that protocol, or the one outlined in the book?
The skin cancer protocol is Ant Crud 200 every morning / Ars Alb 200 every night before bed. eAM is every morning. The other one recommended by a graduate isn't the original protocol, some adaptation. Joette often used Ant Crud in 6C or 200C, so maybe it came from there. I have used the Ant Crud and Ars twice a day, especially when relevant for other parts of the case. Usually we start with the protocol, give it some time, and then adjust if needed. Unless there's urgency. SPPACHH topically can be very helpful as well.
There is a website, homeopathicremediesonline.com, that lists a whole lot of Banerji protocols. Do you know if they are official, accurate Banerji protocols?
Hi Brenda, They are not an official site for the Banerji Protocols, and are not affiliated with the Banerjis. They do have many that are accurate, taken from the books. But to confirm, only the original book, plus the additional protocols book, will do. We were discussing this in the most recent Homeopathy Meet Up and Q&A. There are many sites that post lists of 'new' Banerji protocols. There are NO new protocols. Most of what I have seen on the site you mention are taken from the books, and they tend to note when it is their add-on option. But just because they have it listed as a Banerji protocol doesn't mean it is. So do check for yourself. It is also a VERY expensive way of getting the protocols for the medicines. You don't have to pay for them to coordinate them. You can just buy the homeopathic medicines. I do buy from that source occasionally, but only when I can't find a remedy elsewhere- typically a radiation remedy, or Miralax for clearing, or something really hard to find.
Emily, I really appreciate your thorough research, breakdown & comparisons with the publications and also all the background details you included that clears out some of the misunderstandings and mystery surrounding the editions. The correction lists you provide are such a valuable resource in themselves to create a very easy straightforward path for others. Thank you so much for doing this & your help always. L
Emily-I enjoy reading your blogs so much. I follow Joette also but your explanations are thorough and concise. Can’t wait for your next one. B
Hi Emily - I own Additional Banerji Protocols from the Clinic by Nimisha Parekh and have found it to be a valuable resource as well. It was recently shared with me that some people feel the book isn’t trustworthy because they believe she only visited the Banerji Clinic for one day and then compiled protocols from others. Have you heard of people questioning her credibility or know what may have led to that?
Hi Nichole, I don't know precisely how much time Nimisha spent at the clinics, but the only place that I heard similar things (as you shared) was during my year at the Academy of Practical Homeopathy. Joette Calabrese basically does not acknowledge the Additional Banerji Protocols book, and yet when test time came, the protocol for Diabetes, which is only found in the Additional Protocols book, was expected to be known on the tests. The Additional Protocols are perfectly in line with the original ones, I have used them extensively, and in a short course I did with Nimisha it is clear she got to know the Banerjis, and also uses the protocols herself extensively. :)
Thank you - that’s very helpful. I do have two follow-up questions about the skin cancer protocol on page 60.
First, what does “eAM” mean? I checked the abbreviation key in the front of the book but didn’t see it listed. Does it stand for every alternate month, or every morning?
Second, a practicing homeopath who completed Joette’s Academy suggested a different protocol: Antimonium crudum 6C and Arsenicum album 200C, 2D. In your opinion, would it be better to follow that protocol, or the one outlined in the book?
Thank you again for your guidance.
The skin cancer protocol is Ant Crud 200 every morning / Ars Alb 200 every night before bed. eAM is every morning. The other one recommended by a graduate isn't the original protocol, some adaptation. Joette often used Ant Crud in 6C or 200C, so maybe it came from there. I have used the Ant Crud and Ars twice a day, especially when relevant for other parts of the case. Usually we start with the protocol, give it some time, and then adjust if needed. Unless there's urgency. SPPACHH topically can be very helpful as well.
I appreciate your accessibility and willingness to help. Thank you!
Hi Emily,
There is a website, homeopathicremediesonline.com, that lists a whole lot of Banerji protocols. Do you know if they are official, accurate Banerji protocols?
Thank you.
Hi Brenda, They are not an official site for the Banerji Protocols, and are not affiliated with the Banerjis. They do have many that are accurate, taken from the books. But to confirm, only the original book, plus the additional protocols book, will do. We were discussing this in the most recent Homeopathy Meet Up and Q&A. There are many sites that post lists of 'new' Banerji protocols. There are NO new protocols. Most of what I have seen on the site you mention are taken from the books, and they tend to note when it is their add-on option. But just because they have it listed as a Banerji protocol doesn't mean it is. So do check for yourself. It is also a VERY expensive way of getting the protocols for the medicines. You don't have to pay for them to coordinate them. You can just buy the homeopathic medicines. I do buy from that source occasionally, but only when I can't find a remedy elsewhere- typically a radiation remedy, or Miralax for clearing, or something really hard to find.
That is very good information to have. I will stick with the sources that I know are authentic. Thanks!!